Forestburgh, NY – Community Profile

Forestburgh, located in the southern part of Sullivan County, is one of the region’s most serene and heavily wooded towns. Known for its vast forests, quiet roads, and private estates, Forestburgh offers an unmatched sense of peace and seclusion while still being close to major Catskills and Hudson Valley amenities. With over 85% of its land forested, Forestburgh lives up to its name. This rural town is prized for its natural beauty, low population density, and strong commitment to preserving its pristine environment. It is ideal for those seeking a private retreat, full-time country living, or a second home surrounded by nature.

Community Vibe

Forestburgh is known for being a quiet escape from busier towns which is perfect for those wanting space, solitude, and fresh air. While being a more secluded environment, community is oriented in a small town way, with close-knit and supportive residents. It attracts buyers seeking a calm, restorative lifestyle with easy access to outdoor adventure.

Housing & Real Estate

Forestburgh features some of the most desirable rural properties in Sullivan County. Homebuyers are drawn to the privacy, natural surroundings, and value compared to busier lake towns nearby. Housing options include:

  • Private wooded estates with acreage

  • Rustic cabins and chalets

  • Lake community homes in areas like Merriewold and Lake Joseph

  • Newer build country homes tucked into forested lots

  • Seasonal cottages and vacation homes

Schools

Forestburgh is primarily served by the Monticello Central School District, which includes:

  • Emma C. Chase Elementary School

  • Robert J. Kaiser Middle School

  • Monticello High School

Families can also access private and alternative education options throughout the county.

Outdoor Recreation

Forestburgh offers some of the most untouched natural landscapes in the region. Residents enjoy:

  • Hiking & birdwatching in the Neversink River Unique Area

  • Kayaking, swimming & fishing in Lake Joseph and Merriewold Lake

  • Hunting & outdoor sports on private and state lands

  • Snowshoeing & cross-country skiing in winter

  • Scenic drives through tree-lined country roads

The town is a paradise for those seeking outdoor tranquility and nature immersion.

Local Amenities & Services

While Forestburgh is rural, essential services are nearby in Monticello, Rock Hill, and Port Jervis. Locally, you’ll find:

  • Small cafés and seasonal spots

  • Historic inns and retreats

  • Community centers and arts venues

  • Quick access to Route 42 and Route 52

Most residents appreciate the balance of solitude with short drives to modern conveniences.

Dining & Local Favorites

Popular places in and around Forestburgh include:

  • The Forestburgh Playhouse Tavern – dining connected to the historic theater

  • The Old Homestead Restaurant (nearby in Monticello)

  • Local pubs, cafés, and country markets in surrounding towns

Because Forestburgh is small, dining destinations in Monticello, Rock Hill, and White Lake are just 10–20 minutes away.

Arts, Culture & Entertainment

Forestburgh has a surprising cultural presence:

  • Forestburgh Playhouse – one of the oldest continuously operating summer theaters in the U.S.

  • Local arts performances, workshops & community events

  • Proximity to Bethel Woods Center for the Arts

Residents enjoy a blend of rural living with easy access to concerts, plays, and festivals.

Commuting & Access

Forestburgh’s location offers privacy without sacrificing convenience. Approximate drive times:

  • NYC: 1 hour 45 minutes

  • Monticello: 10 minutes

  • Rock Hill: 15 minutes

  • Port Jervis: 25 minutes

  • Bethel Woods: 20 minutes

Route 42 connects Forestburgh to major highways and regional destinations.

Community Organizations

  • Forestburgh Volunteer Fire Company

  • Forestburgh Playhouse Community Programs

  • Local lake associations and neighborhood groups

These organizations help maintain a strong sense of community despite the town’s rural nature.

Why Buyers Choose Forestburgh

  • True peace and privacy

  • Heavily wooded, natural environment

  • Spacious properties and private lakes

  • Strong arts and cultural scene for a rural town

  • Proximity to Monticello, Port Jervis, and Bethel Woods

  • Ideal for second homes, retreats, and year-round country living

Forestburgh is perfect for buyers seeking beauty, quiet, and a deep connection to nature—without giving up access to amenities and entertainment.